I think there is a big difference between wanting more manufacturing in the country, and wanting more manufacturing jobs. I think that wanting to stimulate a resurgence in highly automated manufacturing, with high worker productivity, is, in fact, a good thing. No, we shouldn't be looking for theanufacturing sector to be a major source of either job/employment growth, or wage growth, but rebuilding that capability, I believe would be a catalyst and stimulus for innovation. Right now, China is the place to go to build, basically, everything, and I don't think it has to be that way. Having idea people directly connected to manufacturing people, is, I believe, a good thing and can lead to a virtuous cycle of enhanced innovation.
The question regarding manufacturing, Justin, is what kind. I won’t rabbit hole into Vernon’s product lifecycle but I think you’d know where that would take us. We don’t want to make toasters - for instance.
The citing of dishwashers is interesting given
the history of Appliance Park in KY. I wrote a paper in undergrad about re-shoring in 2012. Companies lost quality control with the offshoring boom and as what were once simple items to produce (in line with Vernon) became more customized and as consumer demands for quality grew - a re-shoring movement began. This grew out of a need for R&D to be closer to “the line” to control quality and JIT supply chains also begged cases to manufacture closer to the customer. This could have even represented a new stage of Vernon’s theory.
I don’t disagree with your point that mfg is what rich people think poor people want to do but this article betrays they you don’t understand manufacturing in 2026.
I run a facility that makes a highly important component for the US Navy. We employ ~400 ppl. Design engineers, electro-optical assembly technicians, mfg and quality engineers, production planners - to a person they’d be happy with their kids working there. Manufacturing today is not what you reveal you think it is.
The idea that a CNC machinist today does not have to be extremely fluent in mathematics is laughable. Have you seen the curriculum for lean six sigma? Explain to me MRP logic. I’ll wait. Your idea of manufacturing today sounds somewhat in line with Trumps.
Black and white photos with rows of hundreds of ppl doing the same thing.
That is not today’s A&D, automotive, or medical device mfg plant. I cite these industries on purpose. Remember Vernon.
What a post given they this Manufacturing Week. Look it up.
I get your point BUT. In today’s economy young adults know that without specialists training they will never get those high paying jobs. So if you have poor parents who can’t afford to send their children to college and beyond what’s the alternative! The young people see that their future will be the same old same old. If companies want skilled workers then they should with the help of government train them themselves. Make apprenticeship programs that are geared to what the market needs. Even manufacturing jobs needs skills that have to be taught. As a teen many moons ago, I worked in a factory that put components into the back of TV sets. The assembly line paid well and also offered “piece work” which was like getting a bonus in your pay packet every week because you produced more. I didn’t have to know what those components were or what they did. They used to give them recognisable names. The striped coloured ones were called “candy canes” or “lollipops” lol. It kept me off the breadline and I was able to give my parents a cut of my wages for my other 6 siblings and pay for my room and board. I felt like an adult who was contributing towards the good of my family. In those draconian days us girls were still paid less than the boys in the factory but still I did feel that I was putting my work ethic to good use.
Hi, Justin. My answer to the question is Donald Trump wants more manufacturing jobs because he's mentally stuck in 1955. Period.
I think there is a big difference between wanting more manufacturing in the country, and wanting more manufacturing jobs. I think that wanting to stimulate a resurgence in highly automated manufacturing, with high worker productivity, is, in fact, a good thing. No, we shouldn't be looking for theanufacturing sector to be a major source of either job/employment growth, or wage growth, but rebuilding that capability, I believe would be a catalyst and stimulus for innovation. Right now, China is the place to go to build, basically, everything, and I don't think it has to be that way. Having idea people directly connected to manufacturing people, is, I believe, a good thing and can lead to a virtuous cycle of enhanced innovation.
The question regarding manufacturing, Justin, is what kind. I won’t rabbit hole into Vernon’s product lifecycle but I think you’d know where that would take us. We don’t want to make toasters - for instance.
The citing of dishwashers is interesting given
the history of Appliance Park in KY. I wrote a paper in undergrad about re-shoring in 2012. Companies lost quality control with the offshoring boom and as what were once simple items to produce (in line with Vernon) became more customized and as consumer demands for quality grew - a re-shoring movement began. This grew out of a need for R&D to be closer to “the line” to control quality and JIT supply chains also begged cases to manufacture closer to the customer. This could have even represented a new stage of Vernon’s theory.
I don’t disagree with your point that mfg is what rich people think poor people want to do but this article betrays they you don’t understand manufacturing in 2026.
I run a facility that makes a highly important component for the US Navy. We employ ~400 ppl. Design engineers, electro-optical assembly technicians, mfg and quality engineers, production planners - to a person they’d be happy with their kids working there. Manufacturing today is not what you reveal you think it is.
The idea that a CNC machinist today does not have to be extremely fluent in mathematics is laughable. Have you seen the curriculum for lean six sigma? Explain to me MRP logic. I’ll wait. Your idea of manufacturing today sounds somewhat in line with Trumps.
Black and white photos with rows of hundreds of ppl doing the same thing.
That is not today’s A&D, automotive, or medical device mfg plant. I cite these industries on purpose. Remember Vernon.
What a post given they this Manufacturing Week. Look it up.
Btw - I loved you on MSNBC.
I get your point BUT. In today’s economy young adults know that without specialists training they will never get those high paying jobs. So if you have poor parents who can’t afford to send their children to college and beyond what’s the alternative! The young people see that their future will be the same old same old. If companies want skilled workers then they should with the help of government train them themselves. Make apprenticeship programs that are geared to what the market needs. Even manufacturing jobs needs skills that have to be taught. As a teen many moons ago, I worked in a factory that put components into the back of TV sets. The assembly line paid well and also offered “piece work” which was like getting a bonus in your pay packet every week because you produced more. I didn’t have to know what those components were or what they did. They used to give them recognisable names. The striped coloured ones were called “candy canes” or “lollipops” lol. It kept me off the breadline and I was able to give my parents a cut of my wages for my other 6 siblings and pay for my room and board. I felt like an adult who was contributing towards the good of my family. In those draconian days us girls were still paid less than the boys in the factory but still I did feel that I was putting my work ethic to good use.