Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Just the Facts's avatar

I have to disagree. First, toss out all time periods before 1996. Multiple huge global macroeconomic inefficiencies present in the 1960s fell away during the the ‘70s, like the Gold Standard, Maoism keeping a billion people in China unproductive, monopoly dial up phone calls with exorbitant long distance and international rates instead of broadband internet and pre-Uruguay GATT round tariffs. You simply could not globally source goods and services or gain the scale of global markets like you could in 2024.

Clinton balanced the budget and created a surplus with tax rates that were no biggie, as showed by the tech boom. The problem now is that W started two huge wars and cut taxes, sending debt soaring, Trump has done the same, and neither Obama nor Biden had enough votes in the Senate to restore sane tax rates.

Now we are staring at a steaming hot pile of debt from billionaire-fare tax cuts and Republican wars and the resulting interest expense over 26 years. Every percentage point increase drives Federal interest expense and working class interest expense higher, adding to our deficits. If we had a responsible federal budget that got us back to a slight surplus in good years and much smaller deficits during recessions and wars, rates would fall, interest expense would fall, and investment returns would rise.

Arturo Espinosa Velasco's avatar

I agree with Justin Wolfers that the current level of the federal funds rate looks broadly appropriate for the U.S. economy. With unemployment still relatively low and inflation remaining above the Fed’s 2% target, there is little reason to assume that inflation will automatically converge back to target. Additional tightening may still be necessary if inflation proves persistent.

I would add a broader point. We may also need to reconsider what constitutes a “normal” level of interest rates. The post-2008 period was exceptional: weak investment, excess global savings, very low inflation, massive central-bank bond purchases and an unusually compressed term premium kept both short- and long-term rates extraordinarily low.

Today’s environment is quite different. Large fiscal deficits are competing for savings with a major increase in private investment, particularly in AI, while real yields and the term premium have been normalizing.

So the important question may not be when interest rates return to the low levels of the post-2008 financial crisis era, but whether those levels were ever a useful benchmark for normality. Higher rates may not simply reflect a temporarily restrictive Fed; they may also be part of a new interest-rate regime.

2 more comments...

Ready for more?